All posts
3 min read

Correlation Is Not Causation, But It's a Start

Population studies tell you what works on average. Personal correlation data tells you what might work for you. Here's why that distinction matters.

You've heard it a thousand times: correlation is not causation. It's the first thing anyone says when you mention that your sleep improved after starting magnesium. And they're right, technically. But that caveat, applied too broadly, can paralyse you into never learning anything from your own experience.

The truth is more subtle. Personal correlations aren't proof, but they're the best compass most of us have for navigating supplement decisions. Used correctly, they're far more actionable than the population-level studies we usually rely on.

The limits of clinical evidence

Randomised controlled trials are the gold standard of medical evidence, and for good reason. They control for confounding variables, use large sample sizes, and measure specific outcomes rigorously.

But they have a fundamental limitation for personal supplement decisions: they measure averages. A study might show that magnesium glycinate improves sleep quality by 12% across 200 participants. That's useful information. But it tells you nothing about whether you are in the group that improved, the group that saw no change, or the small group that actually slept worse.

Population data gives you a reasonable prior, a starting point. It doesn't give you a personal answer.

What your own data can tell you

When you track your supplement intake alongside subjective outcomes (sleep quality, energy, mood, recovery) over 30 or more days, something interesting happens. Patterns emerge that are specific to your biology, your lifestyle, and your particular combination of supplements.

These patterns are correlations, not controlled experiments. They can't tell you why something is happening. But they can tell you that something appears to be happening, which is often the more useful question.

Consider a few examples:

  • You notice that your sleep scores are consistently 15% higher on days you take magnesium before bed
  • Your energy ratings dip on weeks when you skip your B-complex
  • Your mood scores show no relationship to the expensive adaptogen blend you've been taking for three months

None of these are proof. All of them are actionable. The first two suggest something worth continuing. The third suggests something worth dropping, or at least testing more deliberately.

What Personal Insights actually compares

Personal Insights compares the days you took a supplement with the days you skipped it, and it waits for enough of each to be worth reading: at least 3 days on and 3 days off, each with a check-in. Below that it says what the record still needs rather than showing you a pattern. The longer you log, the more your record holds.

This isn't about generating a single dramatic insight. It's about gradually building a clearer picture of what changed while you took each one. After 30 days, you might see tentative signals. After 90, those signals either strengthen into reliable patterns or fade into noise. Both are useful outcomes.

The key principle: your data doesn't need to be perfect. It needs to be consistent. A rough sleep score logged every day for two months is infinitely more useful than a precise sleep score logged sporadically for six.

From correlation to protocol

The practical workflow is straightforward. Track consistently. Review your correlations. Form a hypothesis: "magnesium seems to help my sleep." Then test it deliberately: drop the supplement for two weeks and see if the pattern holds.

This is the scientific method applied to a sample size of one. It won't get published in a journal, but it might save you hundreds of pounds a year on supplements that aren't doing anything for you.

Correlation isn't causation. But when it's your correlation, tracked consistently over time, it's the most honest data you have.

[Start a record of what you take at Stack Almanac.](https://stackalmanac.com)

Related reading

Check this across your whole routine

Paste the supplements you take. The free check adds up the totals, shows where products overlap, shows general timing information and works out monthly spend, before you create an account.

Audit your supplement routine

Occasional field notes

Useful reading, when we have it.

New evidence guides and meaningful product updates. No daily drip, no supplement sales pitch.

Unsubscribe any time.